*Disclaimer: I have not actually watched Keeping Up With The Kardashians. Ever. I have however, been privy to all the hub-bub surrounding the episode in which Kourtney gave birth*
And here’s my beef; while I am absolutely on board with the admonishment of elective cesarean sections and whole-heartedly believe the medical community as a general population is incredibly over-obsessed with the dreaded pitocin (as a woman who has been ripped in half hip-from-hip by it like a Thanksgiving Wishbone how could I not?) but I’m also not sure the current trend in childbirth discussion — especially online recently and in light of Kourtney’s televised birth — is any healthier.
I’ve had two children. Both births were vaginal deliveries. Both births were a unique experience. Both births rate among the top experiences of my lifetime. Neither birth was “zen”. In any sense of the word. I yelled at least once both times — the second birth I yelled a LOT.
Guess which birth I would choose to do again if I had to. That’s right, the second. And not because of the lack of epidural, I can tell you that much. I would choose to have another birth like my second because of the intense pain, because of the feeling of primal strength. There was nothing “zen” about that experience. Not a damn thing. I screamed like hell and I distinctly remember telling a nurse off. My husband was, at the time, thoroughly intimidated and literally made sick by the amount of pain I was in. But you know what? That’s okay. Because it wasn’t about him.
As a matter of fact, and I know this is probably going to get me some nasty hate mail, but it wasn’t about my baby either — who, by the way, is happy, healthy, thriving five year-old today — it was about me. Believe it or not that experience changed me; that experience equipped me for the unique trials that would follow; it gave me the perspective I needed to raise the baby that was the product of it.
When I gave birth to my oldest I sat up and looked down when she had crowned and saw her beautiful full head of hair — not in a mirror, but right there with my own eyes — and I was overcome with emotion. If every woman in the world could have that experience it would truly be a gift to humanity. It was a raw, awe-inspiring moment. That said, it was what I needed when I was giving birth to my first. I was unsure, I was educated about what was supposed to be happening, what would be coming, but I was scared. There was immense trepidation. I needed that wave of emotion, I needed that boost of pure heart.
When I gave birth to my second I didn’t know it at the time but what I would need was not raw emotion of the heart, but rather strength. Her birth provided that. Was the atmosphere a little more “negative” than the first time around? I guess some would say so. I certainly didn’t feel it. I felt more intense, more deeply focused on the physical aspects of the moment, more absorbed in me, but certainly not negative.
You see, my oldest was an easy baby. She was an easy toddler. It’s only been in the past year or so as she slowly picks up a bit of tween attitude that she has been at all challenging. For all of that we’re thankful. The emotional attachment that came from her calm(er), more deliberate delivery was a perfect start to our journey with her.
My youngest on the other hand, has been difficult. I often joke that she’s had my number since the moment of conception. She’s a person all her own. She’s passionate and energetic and too smart. I needed the primal, superhuman strength that I experienced during her birth to survive her first five years of life. Literally. Needed. What I didn’t need was to be overcome with love, admiration, awe. I needed strength. I got it.
All this to say, birth should be natural — as natural as possible — it should be something that women look back on as a positive experience in their history. It should help prepare them for their road ahead. Birth should be a course in preparation all its own. But this doesn’t mean it has to be zen. It doesn’t mean orca calls should play in the background (unless the mother enjoys orca calls, in which case by all means!). It doesn’t mean there needs to be candles or massages or water or sunshine bursting forth over strawberry fields. It doesn’t mean that if you ask for an epidural you’ve failed. Or that if you told the nurse you would suffocate her with her own rubber gloves after the ten millionth check of your cervix that you’re a bad person.
Any person who has witnessed any number of animals giving birth in person can tell you that a natural birth is not always a pretty thing. They can tell you that the mother was in pain, that during at least some portions of the birth she was entirely focused on herself, they’ll also tell you that sometimes assistance is needed and when that happens it does not automatically mean the resulting baby will be lesser than its counterparts.
Rather than focusing on what is better and what is worse in the world of birthing why not focus on how to reassure one another that it is possible; that birth is nothing to be scared of; that no matter how it happens, no matter if you choose medical pain management or not birth is an experience that will change your life forever? Why not shout from the rooftops that — like babies — happy, healthy births come in all shapes, all sizes, all durations of time; they happen in hospitals, in homes, in birthing centers and sometimes in cars, and in the back of ambulances. And if you’re open to just being present for the experience they will give you something you really need at that time in your life — whether it’s a raw moment of bonding emotion or a six-hour exercise in primal strength. Just be. And when you’re done, be proud. You gave birth.